This article/write up was initially published in my old blog which can be found here.

This is one of earliest article and has hardly any original content and hence my apologies are due.

CMB-R

The Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation (CMB), conclusive proof of the Big Bang, was termed by some scientist as “The Face of God”, perhaps taking a cue from Einstein’s famous “mind of God” phrase. Some scientists actually cried after seeing this “beautiful” image ( that comes from Michio Kaku).

During the first few days of the Universe, the Universe was in full thermal equilibrium, with photons being continually emitted and absorbed, giving the radiation a blackbody spectrum. As the Universe expanded, it cooled to a temperature at which photons could no longer be created or destroyed. The temperature was still high enough for electrons and nuclei to remain unbound, however, and photons were constantly “reflected” from these free electrons through a process called Thomson scattering. Because of this repeated scattering, the early Universe was opaque to light.

When the temperature fell to a few thousand Kelvin, electrons and nuclei began to combine to form atoms, a process known as recombination. Since photons scatter infrequently from neutral atoms, radiation decoupled from matter when nearly all the electrons had recombined, at the epoch of last scattering, 379,000 years after the Big Bang. These photons make up the CMB that is observed today, and the observed pattern of fluctuations in the CMB is a direct picture of the Universe at this early epoch.

-Wikipedia
But they story about it’s discovery is rather entertaining and also leaves many people disillusioned.

Here is an excerpt from A Short history of Nearly Everything (an extremely delightful book!)

There is of course a great deal we don’t know, and much of what we think we know we haven’t known, or thought we’ve known, for long. Even the notion of the Big Bang is quite a recent one. The idea had been kicking around since the 1920s, when Georges Lemaître, a
Belgian priest-scholar, first tentatively proposed it, but it didn’t really become an active notion in cosmology until the mid-1960s when two young radio astronomers made an extraordinary and inadvertent discovery.

Their names were Arno Penzias and Robert Wilson. In 1965, they were trying to make use of a large communications antenna owned by Bell Laboratories at Holmdel, New Jersey, but they were troubled by a persistent background noise—a steady, steamy hiss that made any
experimental work impossible. The noise was unrelenting and unfocused. It came from every point in the sky, day and night, through every season. For a year the young astronomers did
everything they could think of to track down and eliminate the noise. They tested every electrical system. They rebuilt instruments, checked circuits, wiggled wires, dusted plugs.

They climbed into the dish and placed duct tape over every seam and rivet. They climbed back into the dish with brooms and scrubbing brushes and carefully swept it clean of what they referred to in a later paper as “white dielectric material,” or what is known more
commonly as bird shit. Nothing they tried worked.

Unknown to them, just thirty miles away at Princeton University, a team of scientists led by Robert Dicke was working on how to find the very thing they were trying so diligently to get rid of. The Princeton researchers were pursuing an idea that had been suggested in the 1940s by the Russian-born astrophysicist George Gamow that if you looked deep enough into space you should find some cosmic background radiation left over from the Big Bang. Gamow
calculated that by the time it crossed the vastness of the cosmos, the radiation would reach Earth in the form of microwaves In a more recent paper he had even suggested an instrument that might do the job: the Bell antenna at Holmdel. Unfortunately, neither Penzias and
Wilson, nor any of the Princeton team, had read Gamow’s paper.

The noise that Penzias and Wilson were hearing was, of course, the noise that Gamow had postulated. They had found the edge of the universe, or at least the visible part of it, 90 billion trillion miles away. They were “seeing” the first photons—the most ancient light in the
universe—though time and distance had converted them to microwaves, just as Gamow had predicted.

Still unaware of what caused the noise, Wilson and Penzias phoned Dicke at Princeton and described their problem to him in the hope that he might suggest a solution. Dicke realized at once what the two young men had found. “Well, boys, we’ve just been scooped,” he told his colleagues as he hung up the phone.

Soon afterward the Astrophysical Journal published two articles: one by Penzias and Wilson describing their experience with the hiss, the other by Dicke’s team explaining its nature.

Although Penzias and Wilson had not been looking for cosmic background radiation, didn’t know what it was when they had found it, and hadn’t described or interpreted its character in any paper, they received the 1978 Nobel Prize in physics.

The Princeton researchers got only sympathy. According to Dennis Overbye in Lonely Hearts of the Cosmos , neither Penzias nor Wilson altogether understood the significance of what they had found
until they read about it in the New York Times .

This is most probably one of my most favorite anecdotes of all time and it really makes me wonder about the relative value that one should attach to fame, recognition and satisfaction. I feel bad for Prof Dickie.

You can read a more hilarious and cynical attitude about this at Cracked.com ( see #4. Two Guys Win the Nobel Prize in Physics for an Accident)

The Wikipedia article can be found here

 

“Our story is the story of the universe. Every piece of everyone, of everything you love and everything you hate, of the thing you hold most precious, was assembled by the forces of nature in the first few minutes of the life of the universe, transformed in the hearts of the stars or created in their fiery deaths. And when you die, those pieces will be returned to the universe in the endless cycle of death and rebirth. What a wonderful thing it is to be part of that universe. What a story, what a majestic story.”

         -Professor Brian Cox
Particle Physicist( FRS, ATLAS, University of Manchester), ex-D:Ream! Keyboardist.
Prof Cox is a particle physicist and is an inspiration to countless physics students and enthusiasts like me. In his own words, is the one with the most exciting job in this world. His job is to understand how the tiny particles of matter behave and how they are held together. What forces operate on them. And if he is lucky, to find out why they are really here at all :) . He is the leader in making nerd the new sexy! :)

b00zm833_640_360 (1)

“Some people seek meaning in life through personal gain, through personal relationship, or through personal experiences. However, it seems to me that being blessed with the intellect to divine the ultimate secrets of nature gives meaning enough to life.”

 ― Michio Kaku, Hyperspace: A Scientific Odyssey Through Parallel Universes, Time Warps, and the Tenth Dimension
Image

“to Professor Amal Kumar
Raychaudhuri of Presidency College, Calcutta – Generations of Indian students owe their
Classical Mechanics to you!’’

A quote from the late Narayan Rana’s book Classical Mechanics (coauthored with P S Joag), who dedicated the book to Prof Raychaudhuri

Everyone is fascinated with Modern Physics : Quantum Mechanics, String Theory, Dark Matter, The Higgs and what not. So was I. I still am. But the problem was that it made classical physics sound dry and boring. The sole motivation for studying it was because I realized that it was crucial to do so in order to have a sound understanding of Physics. It was after all the cornerstone of  Physics. But slowly, I started to realize the intricate mathematical beauty of this whole framework. I was amazed to see how perfectly we could run the world and send a man to the moon using laws which can best be described as intuitive and approximations. Soon enough, I realized that I felt a sense of satisfaction from solving problems( Spiegel’s Theoretical Mechanics is a very good book for problems and exercises) ; not exactly pleasure but satisfaction. Although I have achieved very  limited mastery over this subject and have a lot more to learn but recently I found another motivation, or rather a sort of incentive, to study classical mechanics with more enthusiasm.

To be honest, a year back, I was blissfully unaware of this man called Amal Kumar Raychaudhuri . It was almost by accident that I came across an article on the web where something called the “Landau-Raychaudhuri Equation”  was mentioned. I found out it had something to do with General Theory of Relativity. I still don’t know GTR except that it is the theory that describes “the very big stuffs” and Physicists are having a hell lot of difficulty unifying it with Quantum Mechanics. What aroused me curiosity was the name “Raychaudhuri”. Not only was the name Indian, but it was a Bengali surname. With very little difficult I was able to link it to the man responsible : Prof Amal Kr Raychaudhuri. However very little information was out there. I was able to find nothing except that he was a Professor of Physics at Presidency College.

However, very recently, I stumbled across a two hour long interview of  Prof Raychaudhuri (I will take the liberty of referring him a Prof AKR for the rest of the post). Patiently, I watched them. And I felt cheated. I felt cheated because here I was looking for role models away from home! Here I was blabbering on about Feynman. But all along, there was such a figure very close at hand.

What I learnt about Prof AKR is that  when he began his Physics career, he had a false start, he had to work in experimental physics at IACS, which reflected neither his wishes nor his talent – he rather wanted to do research in mathematical physics, and he pursued this interest by studying general relativity on his own. The story gets very interesting here ( for me, at least). He left his job at IACS and joined Asutosh College as a lecturer. It was during his stint at Asutosh College, that he developed his interest in GTR. Later he left Asutosh College and re joined  IACS as a Research officer and went on to work on what is now known as the Raychaudhuri Eq (which is again an interesting story in itself). Interestingly this result was used in developing key areas in GTR and one of them was the Hawking-Penrose Theorem.

Why did no one tell me that he was a lecturer at Asutosh College?????No, I am not claiming that Asutosh College had any role whatsoever in his success but I do feel some pride to know that I am an undergrad at the same institution. Obviously he never claimed any close associating with Asutosh College; Presidency (I feel) was more dear to him. Maybe I am dramatizing things in mind or maybe I am feeling a false sense of pride. But I must say it does motivate me. And after watching his interview on Youtube (unfortunately the interview is in Bengali only), I was mesmerized by his simplicity . The video conveyed a feeling  that one would express while conversing with ones grandparent  (Benagli grandsons are somewhat more intimate with their grandfathers/dadus).

To be honest, for me and my humble IQ, it is a long way before I can appreciate the true beauty or depth of Prof AKR’s work in General Relativity and that makes all these blabbering sound like hero worship. It bugs me. Incidentally, our University recommends a book by Prof Raychaudhuri for our course in Classical Mechanics.

I have read that he was a great teacher and his book will provide me with an indirect experience of it. He had even taught Dr Palash Baran Pal , a scientist at SINP  and a great communicator and popularizer of Physics. Incidentally, it was Dr Pal and another one of Prof AKR’s student who requested Prof AKR to publish the book on Classical Mechanics. So, I managed to get hold of a copy of A K Raychaudhuri’s Classical Mechanics today and began reading it immediately. So far, it has been an illuminating experience. The lectures start with a bang, examining critically the drawbacks of Newtonian Mechanics. It then proceeds to the development of Lagrangian formalism of Classical Mechanics. Sadly, I am not being able to devout much time to this area, as it is not included in the syllabus of my first year of study but I have faith on the autodidact inside me. Lets see, if I can make a headway in this direction.

Classical Mechanics: A  Course of Lectures by Prof A. K. Raychaudhuri, OUP 1983

Notes:

IACS: Indian Association of Cultivation of Science

SINP : Saha Institute of Nuclear Research

Asutosh College is an affiliated college of the University of Calcutta

Presidency College is now Presidency University.

Youtube videos :  Interview part I  , Interview part II :

Wikipedia Link to Raychaudhuri EqWikipedia Article on Prof Raychaudhuri ,

A few Biographical Pdfs on Prof Raychaudhuri :ArXiv , IUCAA , IISc, IAS.

A newspaper article from The Telegraph, Kolkata.

Physics has always been synonymous with scientists of exceptional wizard like capabilities. Some have enjoyed/enjoys a great deal of media attention while some toil away in solitude. Some work on popular fields while others hold knowledge of some obscure branch of Physics. Some have been great teachers while others have inspired us with the manner in which they led their lives. Here is such a collection of Physicist . Indeed an odd collection but what the have common is that through their works, their books or the anecdotes from their lives inspire me to carry on and strive to be the best in what I do...... I sound more like a dreamer but I can't help it! PS: I plan to write down briefly how each of these wizards have inspired me but if and only if time permits!

In India, or in almost any third world country for that matter, higher education is synonymous with engineering or the medical profession. I’m not here to debate on how choked up the system is (maybe some other time).

But I am here to justify my choice.

Instead of opting for the cliched Engineering as a career option, I have chose to pursue a course in one of the Basic Sciences, specifically, Physics. The prime reason for that being :

Physics is the branch of science that examines and offers a logical framework to understand the world around us, focused on matter, energy, space and time. It is one of the oldest academic disciplines, a basic science, which has made significant contributions to our understanding of the numerous physical phenomena all around us. The advances and understanding of this field has been translated into new technologies and new ideas.
Thus, Physics is the purest discipline through which one can contribute to the advancement of science and mankind. And in a small way, it will help me realize my dream of leaving a footprint in the sands of time.

I know, it sounds as if I am out of touch with reality but I know the ground realities too : for example, I am quite aware of the fact that I have almost no immediate job prospects compared to my engineer friends and that they would be earning truck loads of money by the time I get my first job. I am also aware of the fact that I will never match them in terms of income and lifestyle. More importantly, I have full knowledge of the level of competition that exists in this field , especially how tough it is do get admitted into an MSc. programme at a decent institution.

But there is more to life than a bank balance. There is something called intellectual curiosity. In today’s world that might seem irrelevant but trust me, it is very important, at least to me! Maybe I will not enjoy life like them but I will have my share of highs. Maybe I will not have my lunch at a high end restaurant but how many of us can understand the first three seconds  after  Creation itself. That’s what I am aiming for, I know it sounds gullible    Also, I am tired of the rat race, and my choice of pursuing Physics has finally allowed me to live my life the way I like : surrounded by books, filled with the knowledge of the ages. I spend my days conversing with the biggest names in history through the souls that they have left on earth and at the end of day, when I go to sleep, that is all that matters ! You live only once, you know!

In case you get stuck in a black hole or something, just remember me. :) (Via : Google Images)

Probably a lot has already been written about the Higgs boson and a lot more is still left to written. For some odd reason this particular discovery has grasped a lot of media attention. The Director General of CERN, Rolf Heuer has even apologized for writing the “b”  of Boson in lower case while delivering a public lecture at the University of Calcutta  on 3rd September 2012 .People who were clueless about the existence of the LHC are now avowed experts on the subjects. Some even claim to have an understanding about it, even though the physicists are themselves clueless about it!

Prof. Higgs and Prof Bose

Obviously that is a big statement coming from an undergraduate student (i.e., your humble correspondent) but thanks to some physicists (who enjoy a high degree of  public attention) laymen and students can gain a working understanding of the whole issue, though it is somewhat mathematical and largely qualitative ( which sort of defeats the purpose of understanding).

(A working (mathematical) understanding of the Higgs Mechanism can be found  here. It has been explained using semi classical arguments mimicking the basic field theory concepts, assuming the validity of a symmetry principle in the expression of the energy of particles in a classical field.)

Now, putting aside absurd claims by religious loonies that Science has finally found god, the Indian (scientific and non scientific community both) , encouraged by the media  has not liked the way this issue has been treated.

People are  ruing over that fact that Dr Satyendra Nath Bose has not been given due credit. The uproar has been so huge that even Phy.org carried an article on it (mocking the absurdity of the whole issue).

While everyone is correct in guessing that the term Boson is named after Dr Bose yet that is not sufficient to attach his name to the discovery. Why? Because of the simple reason that Dr. Bose had almost no role in formulating the Higgs Mechanism. Honestly speaking, one does not need to be aware of the latest development in theoretical or mathematical physics to realize that.

In 1964, Peter Higgs while working on the Electroweak unification involving spontaneous symmetry breaking (an area whose mathematical details I am blissfully unaware of till now), postulated the Higgs mechanism. Now the field associated with the theory needed a Spin 0 particle and this paticle was called the Higgs Boson. Satyendra Nath Bose, during this time was continuing into retirement and was occupying a chair in the University of Dakha.( He finally died in 1974).

So, why is the particle called a boson when Bose had almost no role in this particular theory? Well, Bose along with Einstein had worked out a certain area of mathematics which is know as the Bose Einstein Statistics. All particles having an integer spin( 0, 1 ,2 etc) follow these rules and hence are called Bosons.

/**UPDATE : A small correction is due here ; Pallavi has pointed out that

Einstein did not formulate Bose-Einstein statistics along with Bose! Dr. Bose formulated it on his own and gave his paper to be published in a journal in English. But his paper was rejected. He sent his paper to Einstein after which Einstein simply translated Bose’s work into German and published it in a German physics journal. Einstein’s name thus got attached to Bose statistics.

**/
[Those that follow the Fermi Dirac Statistics are know as fermions and have half integer spins, like the electron (spin half)]

Oh wait, what are spins? Hmm, sorry, I should have cleared this up earlier.In quantum mechanics and particle physics, spin is a fundamental characteristic property of elementary particles, composite particles (hadrons), and atomic nuclei.All elementary particles of a given kind have the same spin quantum number, an important part of the quantum state of a particle.As the name suggests, spin was originally conceived as the rotation of a particle around some axis. This picture is correct so far as spins obey the same mathematical laws as quantized angular momenta do. On the other hand, spins have some peculiar properties that distinguish them from orbital angular momenta, but lets not go into that and if your are overtly curious, Google is always at hand.

So, we have a whole class of particles named after an Indian scientist. Even school children know about a boson; no, not the Higgs but the Photon. I do not hear people grumbling that the Photon is not called the Photo Boson or the fact that  Tata Photon dongles do not acknowledge S N Bose’s “great contribution”.

Well, this is perhaps just a reflection of our post colonial mentality. Indians may feel that Bose do not get sufficient attention in the international arena but it is not so.The Nobel Prize in Physics 2001 was awarded jointly to Eric A. Cornell, Wolfgang Ketterle and Carl E. Wieman “for the achievement of Bose-Einstein condensation in dilute gases of alkali atoms, and for early fundamental studies of the properties of the condensates”. In the Nobel Lectures/Speeches, Bose was fully acknowledged.
It is also interesting to note that it was one of the Gods of the quantum pantheon, Paul Dirac who named the particles Boson (and not something like Einsteion or so).

Though it is an entirely different issue as to why Bose was not given a Nobel during his lifetime but attaching a great name to one of the biggest discovery in particle physics just out of sentimental reasons should not be encouraged. The media should also be reprimanded for sensationalizing news items.

We, as Indians, should take more pride in the fact that Bose had made contribution in one of the most fundamental areas of Physics, having a whole class of particles named after him. Scientists themselves do not seek credit and I am sure they would not like their names to attached to the wrong place!

[Note: As I write this, I seemed to have ruffled up quite a few feathers, especially in Facebook. I was called a fool, had my Alma mater slandered and accused of having an "illusion of knowledge". And I was accused of painting a negative image of a great luminary. Oh well, all for a good cause]

And people who are a bit more curious, here’s a few more links :
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spin_(physics)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spin-statistics_theorem

An article form Lubos Molt’s rather (in)famous blog

On The Higgs Mechanism [ for layman]

On the Electroweak Unification and The Higgs [ for laymen]

Unveiling the Higgs mechanism to ( Undergraduate )students, An arxiv paper :

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.